Are Standing Desks Good For You

Are Standing Desks Good For You

Stand To Work If You Like, But Don’t Brag About The Benefits Shots Health News From NPR Your Health Treatments & Tests Health Inc. Policy-ish Public Health Twitter Your Health Stand To Work If You Like, But Don’t Brag About The Benefits Facebook Twitter Google+ Email March 17, 201611:25 AM ET Angus Chen Enlarge this image An analysis of 20 studies failed to find good evidence that standing at a work desk is better than sitting. Photo illustration by Meredith Rizzo/NPR hide caption toggle caption Photo illustration by Meredith Rizzo/NPR An analysis of 20 studies failed to find good evidence that standing at a work desk is better than sitting. Photo illustration by Meredith Rizzo/NPR I’ve been itching to get a standing desk. After all, America’s sitting itself into an early grave. Sitting is the new smoking. Clearly, a standing desk would stop me from sitting, and standing is just so much better for you than sitting, right? Contrary to popular belief, science does not say so. Too much sitting increases heart failure risk and disability risk, and shortens life expectancy, studies have found. But according to an analysis published Wednesday of 20 of the best studies done so far, there’s little evidence that workplace interventions like the sit-stand desk or even the flashier pedaling or treadmill desks will help you burn lots more calories, or prevent or reverse the harm of sitting for hours on end. “What we actually found is that most of it is, very much, just fashionable and not proven good for your health,” says Dr. Jos Verbeek, a health researcher at the Finnish Institute of Occupational Health. Verbeek says that the studies he and his co-authors analyzed came to conflicting conclusions about whether sit-stand desks reduce sitting time. Even the best research available wasn’t great, the researchers write in the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. The studies were either too small to be significant, the scientists say, or were poorly designed. For example, most were not randomized controlled trials, and the longest study followed participants for only six months. In fact, there isn’t really any evidence that standing is better than sitting, Verbeek adds. The extra calories you burn from standing over sitting for a day are barely enough to cover a couple of banana chips. “The idea you should be standing four hours a day? There’s no real evidence for that,” he says. “I would say that there’s evidence that standing can be bad for your health.” A 2005 study in Denmark showed prolonged standing at work led to a higher hospitalization risk for enlarged veins. But standing doesn’t have to be harmful, says Lucas Carr, a behavioral medicine professor at the University of Iowa who was not involved in the meta-analysis. He thinks as long as you stand in moderation, you can still reap some benefits. “The health benefits of standing are not well-known,” Carr agrees. “But you’re going to burn more calories standing than sitting. I know it’s not a tremendous amount.” Still, he says, “those calories every day over many years will add up.” Carr says the finding of the Cochrane review doesn’t mean that standing desks and variations are useless. It just means there hasn’t been enough study of the desks to say either way. “The state of the science is definitely early,” he says. “There needs to be longer studies with more people to get a good sense these desks actually cause people to stand.” Carr thinks there is the the potential for sit-stand desks to prove useful in preventing healthy office workers from becoming unhealthy. Verbeek is less optimistic. Just because the standing desk or the pedaling desk is in the cubicle doesn’t mean people will get out of the chair and use it. “Changing behavior is very difficult,” Verbeek says. He thinks redesigning work environments might be a better way to go. “For example, organize a printer in the corridor that’s further away from your desk,” he says. Or — and architects can have this one for free — make the one bathroom five flights of stairs up, and restrict use of elevators to people with accessibility needs. ergonomics sitting back pain obesity killer office chairs Facebook Twitter Google+ Email Shots Health News From NPR Shots Health News From NPR About Shots is the online channel for health stories from the NPR Science Desk. We report on news that can make a difference for your health and show how policy shapes our health choices. Look to Shots for the latest on research and medical treatments, as well as the business side of health. Your hosts are Scott Hensley and Nancy Shute. You can reach the Shots team via our contact form. Subscribe RSS @NPRHealth @scotthensley NPR thanks our sponsorsBecome an NPR sponsor
are standing desks good for you 1

Are Standing Desks Good For You

Enlarge this image An analysis of 20 studies failed to find good evidence that standing at a work desk is better than sitting. Photo illustration by Meredith Rizzo/NPR hide caption toggle caption Photo illustration by Meredith Rizzo/NPR An analysis of 20 studies failed to find good evidence that standing at a work desk is better than sitting. Photo illustration by Meredith Rizzo/NPR I’ve been itching to get a standing desk. After all, America’s sitting itself into an early grave. Sitting is the new smoking. Clearly, a standing desk would stop me from sitting, and standing is just so much better for you than sitting, right? Contrary to popular belief, science does not say so. Too much sitting increases heart failure risk and disability risk, and shortens life expectancy, studies have found. But according to an analysis published Wednesday of 20 of the best studies done so far, there’s little evidence that workplace interventions like the sit-stand desk or even the flashier pedaling or treadmill desks will help you burn lots more calories, or prevent or reverse the harm of sitting for hours on end. “What we actually found is that most of it is, very much, just fashionable and not proven good for your health,” says Dr. Jos Verbeek, a health researcher at the Finnish Institute of Occupational Health. Verbeek says that the studies he and his co-authors analyzed came to conflicting conclusions about whether sit-stand desks reduce sitting time. Even the best research available wasn’t great, the researchers write in the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. The studies were either too small to be significant, the scientists say, or were poorly designed. For example, most were not randomized controlled trials, and the longest study followed participants for only six months. In fact, there isn’t really any evidence that standing is better than sitting, Verbeek adds. The extra calories you burn from standing over sitting for a day are barely enough to cover a couple of banana chips. “The idea you should be standing four hours a day? There’s no real evidence for that,” he says. “I would say that there’s evidence that standing can be bad for your health.” A 2005 study in Denmark showed prolonged standing at work led to a higher hospitalization risk for enlarged veins. But standing doesn’t have to be harmful, says Lucas Carr, a behavioral medicine professor at the University of Iowa who was not involved in the meta-analysis. He thinks as long as you stand in moderation, you can still reap some benefits. “The health benefits of standing are not well-known,” Carr agrees. “But you’re going to burn more calories standing than sitting. I know it’s not a tremendous amount.” Still, he says, “those calories every day over many years will add up.” Carr says the finding of the Cochrane review doesn’t mean that standing desks and variations are useless. It just means there hasn’t been enough study of the desks to say either way. “The state of the science is definitely early,” he says. “There needs to be longer studies with more people to get a good sense these desks actually cause people to stand.” Carr thinks there is the the potential for sit-stand desks to prove useful in preventing healthy office workers from becoming unhealthy. Verbeek is less optimistic. Just because the standing desk or the pedaling desk is in the cubicle doesn’t mean people will get out of the chair and use it. “Changing behavior is very difficult,” Verbeek says. He thinks redesigning work environments might be a better way to go. “For example, organize a printer in the corridor that’s further away from your desk,” he says. Or — and architects can have this one for free — make the one bathroom five flights of stairs up, and restrict use of elevators to people with accessibility needs.
are standing desks good for you 2

Are Standing Desks Good For You

In response some people have turned to active desks—be it a standing workspace or even a treadmill desk—but the research on this recent trend has been too scattered to draw clear conclusions on its benefits (and potential drawbacks). At least until now. A trio of Canada-based researchers has analyzed the strongest 23 active desk studies to draw some conclusions on how standing and treadmill desks impact both physiological health and psychological performance. IKEAWhat they found, broadly speaking, is that both types of active desks reduced sedentariness and improved mood without introducing too many workflow complications. More specifically, treadmill desks offered greater health benefits than standing desks did (hello, weight loss), but seemed to interfere more with productivity—at least initially. The researchers published their findings in a recent issue of the journal Preventive Medicine.“Overall, current evidence suggests that both standing and treadmill desks may be effective in improving overall health considering both physiological and mental health components,” they conclude. Here’s a deeper look at what the researchers found.Physiological Outcomes FluidStanceThe evidence sheds light on how active desks impact three measures of physiological health.Baseline. On some baseline physiological measures, such as energy expenditure, both types of active desks showed clear benefits over sitting. Three studies of standing desks found that, on average, participants had an average heart-rate increase of more than 8 beats per minute. Not surprisingly, the impact of a treadmill was even greater here: in two studies, participants walking about 1 mph at their desk showed an average heart-increate of more than 12 beats a minute.Cardiometabolic. Only one study has looked at how standing desks impact clinical metabolic risk factors; it found that a standing workstation could increase HDL cholesterol—aka “good” cholesterol. The encouraging evidence was a bit stronger for treadmill desks. In one study, participants spent nine months using a walking desk instead of their traditional sitter, and registered significant reductions in both total cholesterol and LDL (i.e. “bad”) cholesterol. The best option for many workers might be a hybrid sit-stand workstation.

Are Standing Desks Good For You

Are Standing Desks Good For You
Are Standing Desks Good For You
Are Standing Desks Good For You
Are Standing Desks Good For You

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *